Fundraising, Football, Conflict & Keeping Score | Better Fundraising

This article is written by Jim Shapiro, and was previously published by our Strategic Partner, Better Fundraising.

As Steven mentioned in yesterday’s email, I’ve been a football coach for a very long time. And for the record, my helmet when I played was not leather. 🙂

I’ve noticed some fun similarities between football and fundraising:

• There’s a season for both football and fundraising.  (But the best performers in both arenas practice all year long.)
• Regardless of whatever the “hot new tactic” is, the fundamentals matter a LOT.  In football it’s blocking and tackling; in fundraising, it’s things like your offer and donor segmentation.
• Both have skills you can learn.
• Both have teams that include people with different skills and responsibilities.
• Both use data to measure success.

Fundraising, Football, Conflict & Keeping Score

Finally – but worth spending a moment on – there’s conflict in fundraising and in football.

On the surface, the conflict in football is more physical. But there’s also conflict over who gets to play and who doesn’t. There’s conflict between coaches over what plays to run. (The game is often more draining mentally than physically.)

The same is true in fundraising. There’s conflict between staff over the content and frequency of fundraising. In smaller organizations, there are often disagreements between Board and staff over fundraising methods.

The reason I bring this up is because football has one clear advantage over fundraising in this arena: keeping score is a lot easier. When you try something one week, the scoreboard tells you right away whether it worked or not.

“Keeping score” and knowing whether your fundraising worked or not is more difficult – but it’s more important! The coach in me is constantly encouraging organizations to measure their performance more closely.

A question I ask all the time is, “What is your retention rate for your major donors?” Too many organizations don’t know. They haven’t “kept score” to see whether their fundraising efforts are effective at keeping their major donors around! (And their Majors are often giving more than 80% of the total revenue an organization receives from individuals!)

My encouragement to nonprofits goes back to one of the similarities between football and fundraising that I mentioned at the top: keeping score (measuring the performance of your fundraising) is a skill your organization can learn.

Here are a few of the main metrics we advise nonprofits to track on an ongoing basis:

• Overall donor retention rate
• Major donor retention rate
• # New Donors each year (broken out into New Donors and Reactivated Donors), and the total acquisition costs.  Use those numbers to calculate the Cost Per New Donor.
• For each piece of direct mail: # Sent, # Gifts, Production & Mailing Cost, Gross Revenue.  Use that info to calculate % Response, Net Revenue and Return on Investment (ROI).  Of those, Net Revenue is the most important (not ROI).
• For each email: # Sent, # Open, # Clicks, # Gifts, Gross Revenue.  Use that info to calculate % Open, % Clicks, % Conversion and Net Revenue.
• In addition to tracking the metrics for each impact (email, letter, etc.), we also “roll up” the results for each campaign so we can track campaign efficacy.

That’s just a start, but it’s a good start. If you learn the skill of tracking your performance and then “basing future decisions off of past performance,” your organization gets better faster at fundraising. As a result, you’ll have a larger impact!

This post was originally published on August 19, 2021.
More articles from Better Fundraising can be found here.

At Vanderbloemen, we believe that every organization is unique, and our partner Better Fundraising does, too. That's why both Vanderbloemen and Better Fundraising provide customized and consultative solutions for faith-based organizations.